Individual computer-aided design templates for accurate reduction of unilateral zygomatic-orbital-maxillar complex bone fractures

doi:10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-1366.2016.06.009

Abstract

Abstract:

Objective

To use the individual surface templates of craniomaxillofacial bone in accurate reduction and reconstruction of zygomatic-orbital-maxillar bone fracture.

Methods

Twenty-five cases of unilateral zygomatic-orbital-maxillar bone fracture were observed in this study. Preoperatively, craniomaxillofacial bones were scanned by CT and 3D surface reconstruction of skulls were performed. Then, 3D reconstructions of skull were performed through CT scans. Individual surface templates of fractured side craniomaxillofacial bone, made by technology of electronic computer-aided design (CAD) and rapid prototyping (RP) base on the CT data of unfractured side, were used to guide reduction and reposition of fractured and migrated zygomatic-orbital-maxillar complex (ZOMC) .

Results

Among all cases, the individual CAD templates, were well manipulated in surgery, guiding perfectly reposition and reconstruction of ZOMC. The postoperative horizontal asymmetric rates of each landmark are less than 3%.

Conclusion

On the basis of CAD and RP treatment, the individual templates can be perfectly applied to guide reposition and reconstruction of ZOMC.

Key words: Computer-aided design, Rapid prototyping, Zygomatic fractures, Orbital fractures, Individual templates

Jianping Li, Xing Zhang, Wei Peng, Songling Chen. Individual computer-aided design templates for accurate reduction of unilateral zygomatic-orbital-maxillar complex bone fractures[J]. Chinese Journal of Stomatological Research(Electronic Edition), 2016, 10(06): 414-420.

/ / Recommend

Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

URL: https://zhkqyxyjzz.cma-cmc.com.cn/EN/10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-1366.2016.06.009

https://zhkqyxyjzz.cma-cmc.com.cn/EN/Y2016/V10/I06/414

Figures/Tables 6

References 19

[1]	Czerwinski M, Izadpanah A, Ma S，et al. Quantitative analysis of the orbital floor defect after zygoma fracture repair[J]. J Oral Maxillofac Surg，2008，66(9):1869-1874.
[2]	Strong EB, Sykes JM. Zygoma complex fractures[J]. Facial Plast Surg，1998，14(1):105-115.
[3]	Gassner R, Tuli T, Hächl O，et al. Craniomaxillofacial trauma in children：a review of 3，385 cases with 6，060 injuries in 10 years[J]. J Oral Maxillofac Surg，2004，62(4):399-407.
[4]	Pham AM, Rafii AA, Metzger MC，et al. Computer modeling and intraoperative navigation in maxillofacial surgery[J]. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg，2007，137(4):624-631.
[5]	Ellis E 3rd, Reddy L. Status of the internal orbit after reduction of zygomaticomaxillary complex fractures[J]. J Oral Maxillofac Surg，2004，62(3):275-283.
[6]	Ellis E 3rd, Kittidumkerng W. Analysis of treatment for isolated zygomaticomaxillary complex fractures[J]. J Oral Maxillofac Surg，1996，54(4):386-400.
[7]	Zingg M, Laedrach K, Chen J，et al. Classification and treatment of zygomatic fractures：a review of 1025 cases[J]. J Oral Maxillofac Surg，1992，50(8):778-790.
[8]	Czerwinski M, Martin M, Lee C. Quantitative comparison of open reduction and internal fixation versus the Gillies method in the treatment of orbitozygomatic complex fractures[J]. Plast Reconstr Surg，2005，115(7):1848-1854.
[9]	Farkas LG, Eiben OG, Sivkov S，et al. Anthropometric measurements of the facial framework in adulthood：age-related changes in eight age categories in 600 healthy white North Americans of European ancestry from 16 to 90 years of age[J]. J Craniofac Surg，2004，15(2):288-298
[10]	Eufinger H, Wittkampf AR, Wehmöller M，et al. Single-step fronto-orbital resection and reconstruction with individual resection template and corresponding titanium implant：a new method of computer-aided surgery[J]. J Craniomaxillofac Surg，1998，26(6):373-378.
[11]	Gellrich NC, Schramm A, Hammer B，et al. Computer-assisted secondary reconstruction of unilateral posttraumatic orbital deformity[J]. Plast Reconstr Surg，2002，110(6):1417-1429.
[12]	Watzinger F, Wanschitz F, Wagner A，et al. Computer-aided navigation in secondary reconstruction of post-traumatic deformities of the zygoma[J]. J Craniomaxillofac Surg，1997，25(4):198-202.
[13]	Metzger MC, Hohlweg-Majert B, Schön R，et al. Verification of clinical precision after computer-aided reconstruction in craniomaxillofacial surgery[J]. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod，2007，104(4):e1-e10.
[14]	Westendorff C, Gülicher D, Dammann F，et al. Computer-assisted surgical treatment of orbitozygomatic fractures[J]. J Craniofac Surg，2006，17(5):837-842.
[15]	Kokoska MS, Hardeman S, Stack BC，et al. Computer-aided reduction of zygomatic fractures[J]. Arch Facial Plast Surg，2003，5(5):434-436.
[16]	Al-Harbi SA, Sun AY. Implant placement accuracy when using stereolithographic template as a surgical guide：preliminary results[J]. Implant Dent，2009，18(1):46-56.
[17]	Eggers G, Patellis E, Mühling J. Accuracy of template-based dental implant placement[J]. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants，2009，24(3):447-454.
[18]	Valente F, Schiroli G, Sbrenna A. Accuracy of computer-aided oral implant surgery：a clinical and radiographic study[J]. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants，2009，24(2):234-242.
[19]	Kovács AF, Ghahremani M. Minimization of zygomatic complex fracture treatment[J]. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg，2001，30(5):380-383.

患者序号	Z点		Q点		F点		D点		J点
患者序号	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2
1	12.63	1.56	10.23	1.21	3.21	1.31	3.41	1.30	10.21	1.12
2	10.21	2.10	9.32	1.20	8.12	1.12	3.21	1.12	7.52	1.02
3	11.25	0.94	8.42	1.56	5.13	1.02	3.42	1.32	11.47	1.52
4	9.24	0.96	8.42	2.23	4.34	1.32	2.13	1.45	10.22	1.62
5	9.53	0.67	7.63	1.40	5.12	1.45	2.34	1.21	6.65	1.45
6	8.46	1.23	7.21	1.02	4.21	0.78	4.21	1.11	9.51	0.78
7	6.73	0.89	9.32	1.64	5.13	1.11	2.13	1.24	8.38	1.31
8	6.78	1.63	10.28	1.37	4.36	1.24	2.34	1.54	6.48	1.44
9	12.05	1.98	5.63	0.48	6.34	0.78	3.54	0.89	9.65	1.78
10	12.03	1.32	6.43	1.46	3.54	1.54	2.31	1.01	9.73	1.84
11	11.23	2.11	7.36	1.86	5.31	1.01	2.58	0.78	10.33	1.94
12	9.78	0.56	5.46	0.75	4.87	1.07	4.32	1.31	6.76	2.07
13	11.52	1.42	9.12	2.24	4.32	1.31	2.64	1.50	6.12	1.17
14	10.15	1.25	9.64	2.67	2.64	1.50	6.43	1.23	11.61	1.12
15	11.86	1.64	10.84	1.04	7.32	1.36	3.32	1.51	9.44	1.39
16	9.51	0.79	7.36	1.84	7.23	1.23	2.54	1.31	6.32	1.03
17	8.23	2.02	6.71	1.46	6.54	1.51	2.34	0.73	8.11	1.51
18	5.89	1.45	9.42	1.07	5.34	0.78	5.47	1.52	7.45	1.08
19	13.25	2.80	10.11	2.01	6.34	1.31	5.34	1.03	9.41	1.86
20	7.64	1.36	11.02	1.32	4.98	1.52	2.32	1.02	6.04	1.34
21	7.98	1.32	6.58	1.59	6.32	1.03	2.41	1.71	13.52	1.73
22	12.56	1.20	11.24	0.78	7.41	1.02	5.36	0.49	9.27	1.41
23	7.46	2.01	6.12	2.01	9.12	0.57	5.12	1.13	6.15	0.27
24	13.52	2.11	9.34	1.64	5.12	1.71	4.89	0.75	7.34	1.09
25	10.23	1.32	6.24	1.94	5.54	1.13	2.54	0.68	11.21	1.13

患者序号	Z点		Q点		F点		D点		J点
患者序号	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2
1	12.63	1.56	10.23	1.21	3.21	1.31	3.41	1.30	10.21	1.12
2	10.21	2.10	9.32	1.20	8.12	1.12	3.21	1.12	7.52	1.02
3	11.25	0.94	8.42	1.56	5.13	1.02	3.42	1.32	11.47	1.52
4	9.24	0.96	8.42	2.23	4.34	1.32	2.13	1.45	10.22	1.62
5	9.53	0.67	7.63	1.40	5.12	1.45	2.34	1.21	6.65	1.45
6	8.46	1.23	7.21	1.02	4.21	0.78	4.21	1.11	9.51	0.78
7	6.73	0.89	9.32	1.64	5.13	1.11	2.13	1.24	8.38	1.31
8	6.78	1.63	10.28	1.37	4.36	1.24	2.34	1.54	6.48	1.44
9	12.05	1.98	5.63	0.48	6.34	0.78	3.54	0.89	9.65	1.78
10	12.03	1.32	6.43	1.46	3.54	1.54	2.31	1.01	9.73	1.84
11	11.23	2.11	7.36	1.86	5.31	1.01	2.58	0.78	10.33	1.94
12	9.78	0.56	5.46	0.75	4.87	1.07	4.32	1.31	6.76	2.07
13	11.52	1.42	9.12	2.24	4.32	1.31	2.64	1.50	6.12	1.17
14	10.15	1.25	9.64	2.67	2.64	1.50	6.43	1.23	11.61	1.12
15	11.86	1.64	10.84	1.04	7.32	1.36	3.32	1.51	9.44	1.39
16	9.51	0.79	7.36	1.84	7.23	1.23	2.54	1.31	6.32	1.03
17	8.23	2.02	6.71	1.46	6.54	1.51	2.34	0.73	8.11	1.51
18	5.89	1.45	9.42	1.07	5.34	0.78	5.47	1.52	7.45	1.08
19	13.25	2.80	10.11	2.01	6.34	1.31	5.34	1.03	9.41	1.86
20	7.64	1.36	11.02	1.32	4.98	1.52	2.32	1.02	6.04	1.34
21	7.98	1.32	6.58	1.59	6.32	1.03	2.41	1.71	13.52	1.73
22	12.56	1.20	11.24	0.78	7.41	1.02	5.36	0.49	9.27	1.41
23	7.46	2.01	6.12	2.01	9.12	0.57	5.12	1.13	6.15	0.27
24	13.52	2.11	9.34	1.64	5.12	1.71	4.89	0.75	7.34	1.09
25	10.23	1.32	6.24	1.94	5.54	1.13	2.54	0.68	11.21	1.13

患者序号	Z点		Q点		F点		D点		J点
患者序号	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2
1	13.56	1.21	9.25	1.15	3.65	1.41	6.01	2.06	12.01	1.23
2	11.21	1.20	8.45	1.43	8.75	1.24	5.31	1.94	9.41	1.13
3	12.15	1.56	9.42	0.81	5.64	1.19	5.71	2.01	12.04	1.64
4	10.15	2.23	7.86	0.82	4.83	1.46	3.55	2.13	11.25	1.73
5	10.43	1.40	8.46	0.51	5.64	1.57	3.43	1.89	7.35	1.54
6	9.26	1.02	6.12	0.94	4.67	0.86	7.01	1.49	10.21	0.91
7	7.41	1.64	5.02	0.76	5.67	1.37	3.55	2.01	9.12	1.43
8	7.42	1.37	5.11	1.30	4.83	1.45	3.91	2.50	7.03	1.55
9	13.12	0.48	9.42	1.45	6.94	0.89	5.90	1.51	10.23	1.89
10	13.24	1.46	9.36	1.02	3.98	1.67	3.84	1.61	10.42	1.96
11	12.21	1.86	9.04	1.53	5.76	1.16	4.31	1.31	11.24	2.03
12	10.78	0.75	6.88	0.43	5.13	1.24	7.21	1.31	7.36	2.22
13	12.23	2.24	8.64	1.12	4.83	1.51	4.41	2.42	8.24	1.32
14	11.03	2.67	8.06	0.86	2.98	1.67	10.06	2.16	12.03	1.23
15	12.73	1.04	9.12	1.21	7.76	1.48	5.51	2.43	10.24	1.54
16	10.42	1.84	7.89	0.64	7.68	1.37	4.21	2.11	7.01	1.13
17	9.02	1.46	6.15	1.53	6.98	1.65	3.90	1.20	9.01	1.64
18	6.48	1.07	4.89	1.15	5.68	0.86	9.12	2.51	8.34	1.12
19	14.51	2.01	9.87	2.13	6.69	1.61	8.91	1.70	10.11	1.99
20	8.44	1.32	6.10	1.04	5.34	1.68	3.81	1.64	6.78	1.64
21	8.76	1.59	6.29	1.03	6.76	1.14	4.01	2.51	14.02	1.86
22	13.24	0.78	9.64	0.86	7.86	1.13	8.79	0.71	9.89	1.53
23	8.15	2.01	6.12	1.64	9.61	0.67	8.51	1.64	6.78	0.38
24	14.62	1.64	10.14	1.81	5.57	1.85	8.02	1.23	8.23	1.26
25	11.26	1.94	8.67	1.02	5.96	1.27	4.02	1.06	12.31	1.25

患者序号	Z点		Q点		F点		D点		J点
患者序号	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2	D1	D2
1	13.56	1.21	9.25	1.15	3.65	1.41	6.01	2.06	12.01	1.23
2	11.21	1.20	8.45	1.43	8.75	1.24	5.31	1.94	9.41	1.13
3	12.15	1.56	9.42	0.81	5.64	1.19	5.71	2.01	12.04	1.64
4	10.15	2.23	7.86	0.82	4.83	1.46	3.55	2.13	11.25	1.73
5	10.43	1.40	8.46	0.51	5.64	1.57	3.43	1.89	7.35	1.54
6	9.26	1.02	6.12	0.94	4.67	0.86	7.01	1.49	10.21	0.91
7	7.41	1.64	5.02	0.76	5.67	1.37	3.55	2.01	9.12	1.43
8	7.42	1.37	5.11	1.30	4.83	1.45	3.91	2.50	7.03	1.55
9	13.12	0.48	9.42	1.45	6.94	0.89	5.90	1.51	10.23	1.89
10	13.24	1.46	9.36	1.02	3.98	1.67	3.84	1.61	10.42	1.96
11	12.21	1.86	9.04	1.53	5.76	1.16	4.31	1.31	11.24	2.03
12	10.78	0.75	6.88	0.43	5.13	1.24	7.21	1.31	7.36	2.22
13	12.23	2.24	8.64	1.12	4.83	1.51	4.41	2.42	8.24	1.32
14	11.03	2.67	8.06	0.86	2.98	1.67	10.06	2.16	12.03	1.23
15	12.73	1.04	9.12	1.21	7.76	1.48	5.51	2.43	10.24	1.54
16	10.42	1.84	7.89	0.64	7.68	1.37	4.21	2.11	7.01	1.13
17	9.02	1.46	6.15	1.53	6.98	1.65	3.90	1.20	9.01	1.64
18	6.48	1.07	4.89	1.15	5.68	0.86	9.12	2.51	8.34	1.12
19	14.51	2.01	9.87	2.13	6.69	1.61	8.91	1.70	10.11	1.99
20	8.44	1.32	6.10	1.04	5.34	1.68	3.81	1.64	6.78	1.64
21	8.76	1.59	6.29	1.03	6.76	1.14	4.01	2.51	14.02	1.86
22	13.24	0.78	9.64	0.86	7.86	1.13	8.79	0.71	9.89	1.53
23	8.15	2.01	6.12	1.64	9.61	0.67	8.51	1.64	6.78	0.38
24	14.62	1.64	10.14	1.81	5.57	1.85	8.02	1.23	8.23	1.26
25	11.26	1.94	8.67	1.02	5.96	1.27	4.02	1.06	12.31	1.25

Please choose a citation manager

Content to export